Aruments about why transgenders are harmful to women found on Leftypol thread

WannabeWomanRockstar

Autism and BPD in particular. It's not a shocker that you see the quickest spread of Transgender ideology among people with disorders that are directly linked to Body Dysphoric conditions and have a long history of jumping abord "fad" disorders like how in the 1990s, BPDs and Autists were 100% all in on Bulimia and Pro-Ana.
My genuine view has always been that "Transgenderism" is actually an extremely rare disorder, that might not even be best treated with transition (Name a single other disorder, even body dysphoria that is treated by giving into the disorder completely? Do we treat Anorexia with Ozempic and "semi-healthy" pro-Ana techniques?) that has been through an almagamation of Big Pharma + Liberal LGBT fetishization + Gay Rights professional activists + marketing firms who need a new social crusade to push their products, has led to the current Transgender trend.
The reason I also do not trust a lot of this is that

1: TRA's have a habit of pathologically lying and arguing in bad faith, using very similar techniques or even seemingly copy pasted from Zionists. This is especially in regards to AGP where just a few years ago it was "AGP is a transphobic myth and completely made up" to "Yes AGP is real and it's heckin valid and actually good".
2: Modern Gender theory is completely incoherent and contradictory, as well as metaphysical and comes off as borderline Gnosticism. Another issue with Gender theory is that it's clearly written by Tumblrites who went into Academia with pre-concieved notions and a desire to be a "Good fucking person" rather than actually try find the truth and forumlate a coherent gender theory and profile of the disorder.
3: A lot of the arguments are outright pro-Gay Conversion therapy and are the exact same arguments crazy christians make.
4: Mass slippery sloping. Gender theory has gotten even more Tumblr/Teenage LARP and Fetlife brained as it has gone on due to lack of any coherent "Gatekeeping" (actually having standards and a coherent fucking theory).
5: Predatory actions against women and children. Sorry watched way too many Transgender discords and forums and twitter figures where people engage in horrifically predatory views and grooming behavior towards Children and Women and this stuff is openly encouraged. Completely bonkers stuff and again, a result of lack of gatekeeping and building an actual coherent gender theory and ideology and testing it.
6: Rampant Misogyny. This one is just a no brainer, even Contrapoints talks about the issues of Biological women like a complete fucking smug Psychopath. The narrative in Trans communities against the very real life expeneriences, biological issues of women is honestly unreal. So much toxic, insane rhetoric, and this has turned off even Lefitst female comrades I've spoken to behind closed doors from being unquestionably pro-Trans.
7: Non Binary makes no fucking sense and is completely incoherent and contradictory with the rest of Pro-Transgender ideology. The weird thing is a Non-Binary concept actually makes the most sense in treating Transgenderism imo, BUT as it's presented currently, comes off as completely incoherent and extremely Tumblr LARPing. ON TOP of this, In my local music scene, tonnes of guys who were not gay, in no way dressed or anything "non binary" all claimed they were "non-binary" and started going to womens only events to pick up chicks. I've seen this with my own eyes. But of course, TRA's claim this never, ever fucking happens when it clearly does because I've literally seen it happen and had these guys brag about it to us.
8: Data from UK Gender care clinics, WPATH leaks etc Which shows rampant bad faith, "white lies" and politicization from TRA medical professionals is completely the norm and they openly admit it behind closed doors.

I'm completely open minded to there being more "Genders" than man and women and of course that Gender dysphoria does exist, but I think current Gender ideology is incoherent, toxic, highly politicized and in reality most likely harmful to the people who actually suffer from said disorders. In particular again, I find it bizarre that Gender Dysphoria the actual treatment is giving into the delusion, which is an insane position to take when looking at any other dysphoric condition.

Source: https://leftypol.org/leftypol/res/2181242.html#2182976



 

2

  



 

0